GThe Garcoon
2026 · Week 4
Menu
ESPN LeagueWikiPress BoxSeasonsManagersHall of Fame
Reigning champion: Dietz. Back to back (2024, 2025). Going for 3.
Head to head · Rivalry

Neely vs Mathis

Official fight cardRegular-season series
NeelySh!t B!rds7Wins
VS25 meetings · 0 playoff · 4 consolationMathis won the last one
MathisBucee's Ballers14Wins
Playoff weeksNoneNever met
Points in rivalry2,758.1-2,915.1Regular season
Best week here215.8Mathis · ’16 wk 12

Tale of the tape

Head-to-head, then career
NeelyMathis
131.3Head-to-head avg score138.8
211.4Best score in rivalry215.8
+77.1 (’17 wk 3)Biggest win+61.0 (’13 wk 9)
3Longest streak5
Career numbers
16Seasons15
102-88-2Regular-season record95-84
10-10Playoff weeks9-9
.536Win %.531
27,205.9Career points for23,379.2
20Weekly high scores18

Signature games

2016wk 12Highest combinedNeely 163.4 · Mathis 215.8 · 379.2 totalMathis
2017wk 3Neely’s biggest winNeely 177.3 · Mathis 100.2 · by 77.1Neely
2013wk 9Mathis’s biggest winNeely 54 · Mathis 115 · by 61.0Mathis
2020wk 7Closest gameNeely 103.2 · Mathis 106.2 · decided by 3Mathis

Every meeting

25 games · playoff rounds were 2-week totals

SeasonWeekNeelyMathisResult

202515 Consolation122.3123.9Mathis by 1.6

202514 Consolation147.4146.8Neely by 0.6

202513 96.2112.4Mathis by 16.2

20254 180.1150.7Neely by 29.4

202413 142.1159.6Mathis by 17.5

20244 127.8136.8Mathis by 9

202315 Consolation81.999.5Mathis by 17.6

202314 Consolation87.4141.8Mathis by 54.4

202313 123.5133.7Mathis by 10.2

20236 104.9120.6Mathis by 15.7

202213 156.6148.3Neely by 8.3

20226 100156.2Mathis by 56.2

202113 130161.3Mathis by 31.3

20216 92.5125.5Mathis by 33

20207 103.2106.2Mathis by 3

20197 105.9154Mathis by 48.1

20187 150.2121.7Neely by 28.5

201712 145.6137.9Neely by 7.7

20173 177.3100.2Neely by 77.1

201612 163.4215.8Mathis by 52.4

20163 125.4145.2Mathis by 19.8

20159 211.4137.96Neely by 73.44

20149 151110Neely by 41

20139 54115Mathis by 61

20129 117166Mathis by 49

Other rivalries

All 45 rivalries →
Neely vs
DietzGogoGoldenMathisBakerOettingBielDaunerDavis
Mathis vs
DietzGogoGoldenNeelyBakerOettingBielDaunerDavis
Mirrors the Fantasy HofF rivalry archive, pulled Sept 29, 2026, through Week 3. The series counts regular-season games; playoff and consolation weeks are listed separately.Dispute a result